When Night Always Comes opens with news reports and radio shows hammering the housing crisis – wages too low to cover rent and basic expenses, evictions looming – the promise is clear: a direct plunge into a reality that pushes people to the edge. As the protagonist heads out to work, she worries about her mother and the need to be in the right place, at the right time, with the money, to avoid their own eviction. Directed by Benjamin Caron (Andor) from a screenplay by Sarah Conradt (50 States of Fright), adapted from Willy Vlautin’s novel, the story follows Lynette (Vanessa Kirby, Pieces of a Woman), who lives with her mother, Doreen (Jennifer Jason Leigh, The Hateful Eight), and her brother, Kenny (Zack Gottsagen, The Peanut Butter Falcon), a trio on the verge of losing their home. The mission, brutal in its simplicity: get $25,000 in a single night.
In theory, the premise could have made for a gripping thriller or a devastating social drama. In practice, Night Always Comes hesitates and gets lost somewhere between the two. Everything is spelled out, leaving no room for subtext: characters recount past traumas and present struggles as if reading a report, robbing the audience of any chance at emotional discovery. The night’s plan – scraping together money at any cost, by increasingly unlawful means – is repeated and underlined to exhaustion, as though the film doesn’t trust viewers to grasp what’s at stake.
Still, there’s a strong thematic core rooted in desperation: when everything lawful, kind, and decent fails, people change. Lynette climbs and descends moral staircases at breakneck speed, and Kirby stands out – as expected – bringing weight to a flawed protagonist who commits crimes to protect her family. It’s a deliberately gray arc, and the actress finds humanity in the margins of that darkness: a wavering look before crossing the line, a gesture betraying guilt when urgency silences conscience. If the movie has an anchor, it’s Kirby.
The problem is that everything around her feels disorganized. Night Always Comes can’t decide whether it wants to be a social commentary or an intense thriller. The central plot behaves more like a suspense mechanism than an emotional journey. Scenes meant to deepen Lynette’s past feel like stray ideas rather than narratively coherent beats. The tone stays bleak from start to finish, but the way these vignettes are placed makes them feel out of sync – more calculated to raise the seriousness of the situation than to illuminate the character.
The relationship between Lynette and Doreen, portrayed with Leigh’s usual precision, is the clearest example of this fragility. It’s a half-baked storyline: the attempt to explore the lack of communication between mother and daughter is evident, but the scenes play more like a thesis than a lived experience. What’s missing is organic flow, evolving conflict; what remains is the sense of an idea left underdeveloped.
Night Always Comes also falls into a repetitive cycle: Lynette needs money; she asks for help; that help involves a crime committed either by her or others; consequences follow, from physical to psychological; and in the end, we’re almost back where we started. The narrative feels like a “just one more level” game until it can’t go any further, but without proportional dramatic progression. The dark cinematography and total absence of humor intensify the suffocating mood – technically, the atmosphere is cohesive – but the structural stagnation dulls the impact. Most frustratingly, it soon becomes clear that everything will somehow be for nothing: when the ending arrives, it’s obvious and, therefore, less affecting – there’s no catharsis, only underlining.
Not everything is negative. Beyond Kirby, Leigh finds subtlety in a mother grappling with resentment and fragility, even when the script gives her little room to blossom; and Gottsagen once again proves, with natural ease and presence, what should be obvious: actors with Down syndrome can – and should – inhabit complex roles without paternalism. Technically, the night’s construction is effective: the heavy imagery, the tightening soundscape, the city as an emotional labyrinth. There’s intent and texture. What’s missing is narrative focus.
As social commentary, Night Always Comes raises valid flags – precarity, dehumanizing bureaucracy, families adrift in a system that forces unthinkable choices – but it does so far too literally. Instead of trusting in the ambiguity of situations to engage and outrage us, it spells out what we should feel and why. The message gets across, no doubt; the cinema, however, gets lost in overstatement.
Final Thoughts on Night Always Comes
Night Always Comes falls short of its ambition. There’s a powerful story here – the moral erosion provoked by systems that always fail the same people – but the film never finds the most impactful way to tell it. Atmosphere and performances elevate the material, with Kirby in particular carrying the story’s weight with a commitment that deserved a sharper script. Yet between redundancy, lack of subtlety, and indecision between bitter satire and taut thriller, the experience slips into frustration and overemphasis. When the night ends, what remains is the sense that all that noise amounted to very little meaning.
Rating: C-
Night Always Comes is now playing on Netflix.
Learn more about the film, including how to watch it, at the official website for the title.
You might also like…
